← More behind my thinking

Ryan’s library · My current thinking

Psychology & the Human Experience

What is it like to be across the table from me when I think I’m helping?

Updated November 2, 2026

I can be twenty percent of the way into an idea and sound like I’d bet the house on it. Rich Hoffmann recognized the problem. He sometimes tells people how far along his thinking is so they know what kind of conversation they’re in. From my side of the table I’m trying out a thought. From the other side it can sound like the decision just got made. Then I’m the guy wondering why nobody pushed back.

I want to know what it’s like to be on the other side of me. That’s one thing I can’t learn by thinking harder in my own head.

On this page

How much room did I leave for an answer?

I can ask an owner, “What else could you do?” because I want to hear an idea I haven’t thought of. I can ask the exact same question because I already have an answer and I’m trying to get them to say it. Rich helped me put a finger on the difference. Would I welcome an answer that changed my mind?

When I have a recommendation, I owe the other person the courtesy of saying what it is and why. When I’m still thinking, saying that out loud gives them a way in. Kim Clark and I have talked about when I need her to interrupt me. Sometimes the most helpful thing she can do is get a word in before I’ve talked us both into my first idea.

What does resentment cost me?

I know how fast I get irritated when I think someone wants the benefit of work they’re asking somebody else to do. I wrote about that in an assessment years ago. I can go from noticing who did the work to being pretty sure I know the other person’s motives. By the time we talk, I’ve already had half the argument without them.

There may be a real disagreement to work out. I can say which part felt unfair to me and still ask what I missed. When somebody does that for me, I have a much easier time telling them the truth, including the part I got wrong.

Why is one more project so easy to say yes to?

Learning something new and making progress are two of my favorite feelings. They make a pretty persuasive case for starting another project. A question I kept from The Gap and the Gain is what I’ll have to turn down if I say yes. Now I’m looking at an actual evening on my calendar and the people I might have promised it to.

I’d love to hear about a time somebody helped you change your mind. I’m as interested in what they did that made it easy to speak honestly as I am in the thing they said. Hear my conversation with Rich

Books from my library

Other podcasts and interviews

From my podcast